Fiberglass vs. Steel Doors: Choosing the Right One

When picking a front door for your home, you need to consider a lot. The size, color, and design are all important, but before you can decide on any of those, you need to settle on what kind of materials you want for the door’s composition. There are quite a few options for entry doors, but two of the most common are fiberglass and steel. If you’ve narrowed your selection to these two types but don’t know which door to choose, we’re here to help you pick the right one.

The Argument for Steel

Let’s start by looking at steel. When most people picture a steel door, they think of the plain gray ones they’d find in the back of a business. However, residential steel doors are much more colorful and vibrant. Plus, you can even get ones with glass built into them.

While there’s a decent number of style options for steel doors, that’s often not the primary reason people buy them. They get them because of their strength. A steel door can hold up against anything from nasty weather to burglars trying to break into your house.

Unfortunately, this strength comes with a trade-off. Steel doors require lots of maintenance to keep them in good working order. If you put in the time to take care of your door, though, it’ll last you much longer than anything else on the market.

The Argument for Fiberglass

Now, let’s go over fiberglass and how it compares to steel. First off, fiberglass doors have many more design options than steel ones, making it easier to find a look that best fits the rest of your home. On top of that, it requires no maintenance, which is another huge plus over the competition.

While strong, fiberglass doors aren’t nearly as sturdy as steel. However, one pro they have is that they’re much more energy efficient. That’s not to say that steel isn’t good at saving energy—fiberglass is just better at it.

Which Should You Choose?

Now that you know the key differences between fiberglass and steel doors, which one should you choose? Since there’s no definitive best option, you need to go with the one that best fits your needs. If strength and security are priorities when it comes to your front door, steel is the best choice for you. On the other hand, you might want to go with fiberglass if you want to focus more on aspects like design and energy efficiency.

Regardless of which one you choose, Doors of Pontiac is the place to get it. We sell both steel and fiberglass residential entry doors, as well as many others. Once you decide which door you want, we’ll even professionally install it for you to help ensure it fits your home perfectly.

Leave a Comment

Greg Mcfern
Greg Mcfern
00:50 07 Nov 24
Doors of Pontiac sent out. Al D very knowledgeable! Easy to talk to and had a real nice smile. He fixed the spring and two guide wires took about 2 hours and he finished cleaned his mess up. Nice young man. Yours truly, Greg.11-6-2024
Lou Ann Coder
Lou Ann Coder
20:39 05 Nov 24
Another wonderful job done by a great quality company. The Maintenance tech was very thorough and did a great job on my garage door repair.
Tom Henry
Tom Henry
16:44 05 Nov 24
VIVIAN STEINHILPER
VIVIAN STEINHILPER
12:36 05 Nov 24
Extremely pleased with choosing Doors of Pontiac to replace our garage doors. We went to a number of different stores to price compare, quality of doors, and overall knowledge and helpfulness of staff. Doors of Pontiac staff were professional and helpful in selecting the garage door that best suited our needs. The installer Dan was on time, professional, courteous, and answered all our questions. We could not have asked for a better experience throughout the entire process. We highly recommend Doors of Pontiac!
Wayne Smith
Wayne Smith
20:01 04 Nov 24
Great experience and Drew did a great job
Fred Bause
Fred Bause
16:22 04 Nov 24
Jon Wells
Jon Wells
13:19 04 Nov 24
Did great work 👍
Lawrence Ricci
Lawrence Ricci
15:51 31 Oct 24
david meeker
david meeker
14:32 31 Oct 24
Called late afternoon for garage door serviceArrived first thing next morning fixed right awayTechnician Keaton friendly, knowledgeable, efficient. Five star experience all around.
LEONARD Dicks
LEONARD Dicks
23:30 29 Oct 24
John Polomski
John Polomski
17:50 29 Oct 24
Great work and fast
Ryan Boucher
Ryan Boucher
19:54 28 Oct 24
Had some garage door issues and Doors of Pontiac was amazing. Great customer service and quickly set me up for an appointment with great prices. They sent out Justin and I could not have been more impressed with him. Super personable and did not try to push any extras. Don't pass this place up if you need work done and ask for Justin.
Kathy Perrotta
Kathy Perrotta
19:11 28 Oct 24
Janet Clark
Janet Clark
17:37 28 Oct 24
Justin did a great job. Attention to detail and tested and retested until everything was running smoothly.
John Maloney
John Maloney
15:54 28 Oct 24
Great experience. Keaton very knowledgable and fixed the issue I had. He took the time to answer my questions and did NOT push to sell me. New garage door. Highly recommend.
Tim Merritt
Tim Merritt
15:01 26 Oct 24
We discovered a broken garage door spring on a Friday evening, a very inconvenient time! We contacted Doors of Pontiac, they had a tech at our home on Saturday morning and had our door working again before the noon college football kickoff!!
John Davis
John Davis
22:27 24 Oct 24
Quick response and great service. Did a quick adjustment after a year later free of charge.
Susan Potrykus
Susan Potrykus
19:26 24 Oct 24
I appreciate the great work completed by Dan from Doors of Pontiac. Great job
Tom Cotter
Tom Cotter
21:25 23 Oct 24
Susan Wheatley
Susan Wheatley
20:24 23 Oct 24
Ingerbord Morrison
Ingerbord Morrison
17:45 23 Oct 24
Friendly, on time, respectful of property! Very Professional! Great job.
Andy Hoke
Andy Hoke
13:20 23 Oct 24
If you need a new garage door, Doors of Pontiac should be your first choice. I had several quotes and Pontiac Doors was not the cheapest. However, past experience with this company made my decision easy. From consulting with the office to installation of my beautiful new garage door was a A+ experience. The installation team was top notch. Dan and Devon did a spectacular job doing the removal and installation. They showed up early, respected my property and kept me informed. Dan and Devon are total professionals. They even showed me how to properly lubricate my new door and at what intervals. In these times of marginal service Doors of Pontiac rocks!
Phil Winnicki
Phil Winnicki
18:05 22 Oct 24
Mike has been great...thank you, and thanks Doors of Pontiac.Nice work
Carlotta Quince
Carlotta Quince
14:48 22 Oct 24
My experience with Doors of Pontiac was stellar! On the first visit (of two), Tech Andy arrived promptly to assess damage to my garage door. In no time, he explained clearly what needed to be done; made the repair; and reinforced the door's framework from the inside out. I also purchased a much needed backup garage door opener for a good price in the same visit. Kudos to Andy for his proficiency and professionalism! In setting up this visit, kudos also to Office rep, Yvette, whose caring, courtesy, and professionalism in taking down my concerns over the phone was palpable and made me look forward and relieved to seeing Andy show up at my door! For visit two, Office rep Staci Q was very effective in listening to my concerns and forwarding pics to Tech Bob prior to his arrival; to give him a solid "heads-up". While a door replacement seemed imminent, Bob demonstrated master craftsman skills and repaired the door and door locks to work as good as new! And for a price you can't beat! This company is the one to call when you need help with garage doors or ANY other doors in my opinion! Keep up the good work!And thank you.
Liz Lesnau
Liz Lesnau
09:08 22 Oct 24
I was very satisfied when Justin came out to fix my garage door. Very informative on what he was going to fix. Thank you.
Paul Allen
Paul Allen
02:47 22 Oct 24
Had a couple small issues, but everything was taken care of promptly. thank you
Isabel Quintana
Isabel Quintana
18:45 21 Oct 24
Very good and fast service. Pleased with this company. Would recommend to friends
Frontroom Jackson
Frontroom Jackson
14:50 21 Oct 24
Samantha Vansaw
Samantha Vansaw
12:53 21 Oct 24
Margie Loveland
Margie Loveland
16:35 19 Oct 24
Great service! Doors of Pontiac employee Gage came out quickly to fix our church’s door. He was on time, efficient and repaired it within an hour. Very pleased with this company!
Elaine Chapman
Elaine Chapman
13:46 19 Oct 24
Excellent service!
christal sharlow
christal sharlow
15:19 18 Oct 24
Service was quick and reliable. Very satisfied with their work.
Margaret Martin
Margaret Martin
02:48 18 Oct 24
The gentlemen from Doors of Pontiac, Keaton & Josh, who came out to install our new garage door opener were professional, courteous and knowledgeable. They came out same day and got the job done quickly. They were friendly and helpful to program all our remotes to open both garage door ports. They cleaned up all the old parts and haul them away. We are repeat customers and have come to the trust the quality of workmanship Doors of Pontiac provides. Keep up the great work!
Jen Bracken
Jen Bracken
20:59 15 Oct 24
Cherie Salas
Cherie Salas
17:09 15 Oct 24
We love our new door from Doors of Pontiac. Jeff was our installer and he was very thorough. He kept us informed through every step of the installation. He was very friendly and professional as was everyone we dealt with at Doors of Pontiac. We highly recommend this business.
Todd Arnott
Todd Arnott
23:02 14 Oct 24
Patricia Cumbee
Patricia Cumbee
20:31 14 Oct 24
Appreciate the great service!
Susan Campagnolo
Susan Campagnolo
19:28 12 Oct 24
I called first thing Saturday morning and someone was able to come out right away. The garage door was fixed in approximately 1hr. It was a great experience.
Elisabeth Stevens
Elisabeth Stevens
16:28 12 Oct 24
I was once again, impressed with the level of service provided by Doors of Pontiac. The technician, Harold, was prompt, courteous, efficient, and polite. He explained what the problem was and made all repairs quickly. I will call on Doors of Pontiac and recommend them again and again.
David Willens
David Willens
23:43 11 Oct 24
friendly scheduler got us same day service. Solved a wiring problem that nobody else could over several years within 30 minutes! Couldn’t have been happier.
D J
D J
13:55 11 Oct 24
Keaton Pearson
Keaton Pearson
21:47 10 Oct 24
I needed an Entry door for my home and Doors Of Pontiac were pleasant to deal with. Randy, Jeff, and Billy showed up on time went above expectations on getting my door installed!
Joe DeMaria
Joe DeMaria
16:35 10 Oct 24
Great customer service from the designer, estimator and installer. Highly recommend.
sklobucar0
sklobucar0
17:53 09 Oct 24
Dylan was very professional told me all the things that needed to be fixed and did the repairs quickly and efficiently
Kimberly McAdams
Kimberly McAdams
20:20 08 Oct 24
Dan and Deven showed up on time. Painted the screw heads to match trim and did a wonderful job!!!!!! What a GREAT company!!!!!! Pricing was 1/2 what we were quoted elsewhere. Would highly recommend this company!!!
Claire Ziobro
Claire Ziobro
17:43 08 Oct 24
Good service and kind thanks to all.
Marc Kanitz
Marc Kanitz
20:16 07 Oct 24
Our garage door spring snapped, so manually lifting the door repeatedly was not going to be an option due to the weight. I was worried that we’d have to wait a couple weeks to get it going again. With small kids on a busy road, herding them into the car is always safer and easier inside the garage. On a Monday morning, Evette with scheduling quickly found a tech/solution for us, by Monday afternoon Justin had the door repaired and updated. Justin was very professional and knowledgeable. Less than 8 hours after my first call, the problem was solved. Bravo.
Cara Feldpausch
Cara Feldpausch
15:36 07 Oct 24
Justin from Doors of Pontiac was great! He was to my house quickly, he was friendly, knowledgeable and competent with the repair of my garage door. He fixed the spot that was broken and inspected the door to make sure there weren’t issues elsewhere. He also gave me information on a new door because mine will need to be replaced soon. Reasonable price. Definitely recommend!
edward brackins
edward brackins
15:35 07 Oct 24
always provides me with great service
Phil Janness
Phil Janness
01:41 07 Oct 24
erin meilak
erin meilak
18:14 04 Oct 24
K.M. Sylvestre
K.M. Sylvestre
15:06 04 Oct 24
Jeff and Bob were friendly and professional and clearly experts in their field. They made sure we were satisfied and did a thorough cleanup they left the site. I do have one recommendation: Bob should keep his day job because, try as he might, his humor is just not ready for prime time.
Diana Thomas
Diana Thomas
13:54 04 Oct 24
Harold was incredible! I had appointments scheduled & couldn’t even get out of the garage. Harold arrived within 15 minutes & had the springs replaced in no time. From the time I called till the job was done was under an hour!
Daniel Rinkevich
Daniel Rinkevich
13:25 04 Oct 24
The new door looks and works great! It really updates the look of our 1975 vintage house. The guys that installed the door were very nice and knowledgeable. The guys did a great job. Doors of Pontiac did a great job of keeping us up to date on who was coming and when to expect them with text alerts. I would recommend Doors of Pontiac.
Major Miner
Major Miner
17:46 03 Oct 24
Rod Rhodes
Rod Rhodes
19:42 02 Oct 24
Fast and friendly service.
Jan Sullins
Jan Sullins
16:09 01 Oct 24
Gage was very nice and thorough and professional. He fixed my lock on the spot and ordered the required parts for repair. I Would highly Recommend doors of Pontiac Livingston for all of your doors.
Thomas Smith
Thomas Smith
14:40 01 Oct 24
Mike did a thorough and great job. Explained everything we needed to know about the door.
Bryce Ferguson
Bryce Ferguson
01:03 01 Oct 24
Keaton was excellent, very patient and soft spoken described my problem in ways I can understand. doors of Pontiac is great ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️
Josh Herman
Josh Herman
23:03 30 Sep 24
The spring broke on my garage door, but Keaton came out the same day and got the door working safely again! He also showed us a few parts on our door that were making noise and now it's quieter than when it was brand new!
Richard Klug
Richard Klug
22:36 30 Sep 24
Drew is the greatest
John Yorke
John Yorke
16:54 30 Sep 24
Justin did a great job explaining what my garage door needed, communicating when he would meet me, and completing the work correctly.
Darsi Haning
Darsi Haning
14:26 30 Sep 24
Doors of Pontiac offered quick service. They were available next day when I called to schedule service for our garage door springs. After evaluation, Harold quickly got the parts he needed and replaced the spring. Service was done within an hour and pricing was reasonable. I would highly recommend:
Maryann Nagel
Maryann Nagel
14:19 28 Sep 24
I’ve used Doors of Pontiac in the past and again today. They’ve always taken care of things quickly and I’ve always been 100% satisfied. Highly recommend!
timothy martin
timothy martin
18:28 27 Sep 24
The technician Al D did a thorough inspection and completed the repairs in an excellent manner. He explained what needed to be done, lubricated the moving parts and cleaned everything up. Would highly recommend Doors of Pontiac
Ulipamwe Amagulu
Ulipamwe Amagulu
20:42 26 Sep 24
Brenda Loveday
Brenda Loveday
16:57 26 Sep 24
Keaton installed a garage door opener, spring set and trim. He did an amazing job. He was professional, on-time, and conscientious about his work. I highly recommend him and Doors of Pontiac.
Michelle Fuller
Michelle Fuller
14:43 26 Sep 24
Lizzy B.
Lizzy B.
00:24 26 Sep 24
Justin Lyons with Doors of Pontiac rocks! I wish all service people were as calm and people oriented as he is. Appreciated the quick response to come out, look at our garage door and give us a reasonable solution.
Advantage Electric
Advantage Electric
00:17 26 Sep 24
Jamie T
Jamie T
19:54 25 Sep 24
Extremely fast, excellent work. Professional, and priced almost half as much as other quotes I received.
Michele LaPorte
Michele LaPorte
16:29 24 Sep 24
Doors of Pontiac is my extended families go to.I was having a problem with my garage door. Keaton came out. He was on time, polite, explained what he was doing, and fixed the problem.
Rick Wykoff
Rick Wykoff
15:53 24 Sep 24
Herald came out next day after i called for service He quickly replaced the springs on my doorSeems to have done a great jobDoor seems to be functioning well after repairs
Alexis Pollock
Alexis Pollock
12:13 24 Sep 24
Karen and Keaton are the best. I’ve worked with Karen for over 5 years, and she told me how great Keaton is, and she is right! He is so personable and took time to explain everything, set it up, and make sure my door was in its best condition. I always want to work with them!
Julie Papo
Julie Papo
21:28 22 Sep 24
We love our front door!!! Billy and Jeff did a great job installing it!! We were very happy customers!!!
Kevin Chenet
Kevin Chenet
15:56 20 Sep 24
Professional and knowledgeable! Great service
Jalen Hamiel
Jalen Hamiel
21:50 19 Sep 24
I called doors of Pontiac for my mothers broken door, they responded quick and sent Keaton out same day. he diagnosed the issue and fixed it and went the extra mile and replaced parts to make the door quieter for her, I can’t recommend Keaton and doors of Pontiac enough they’re amazing!
Jeffrey Reynolds
Jeffrey Reynolds
21:13 19 Sep 24
I asked Doors of Pontiac to send out a Repair Technician to replace a frayed cable on my two car garage door. Devon came out within the hour & he started off with a safety check of the door mechanism & gave me some suggestions. He set to work on the support cable & he replaced it quickly & efficiently. He was friendly & helpful. I would highly recommend him & I would use him for any future repairs I may need.
Paul Couture
Paul Couture
18:35 19 Sep 24
Justin just fixed my door, which had a broken spring. Called this morning, Justin had it done by 2:30. Much appreciated Justin
Scott Slaith
Scott Slaith
17:59 19 Sep 24
Keaton was great, the service was professionally and quickly completed.
Diane Rowe
Diane Rowe
20:44 18 Sep 24
They came on time and made a repair to the garage door quickly and efficiently. The tech Harold was nice and helpful!
Brian Coats
Brian Coats
19:56 18 Sep 24
Called at 8 am and they were at my house by 1200. Harold was fantastic! He knew exactly what he was doing, no guesswork. He showed up with all the parts he needed and within an hour my garage door was back to work. I have never experienced such great service.
Alice Currier
Alice Currier
21:48 17 Sep 24
Doors of Pontiac takes care of its customers year after year. We had Justin service our home toady and he was outstanding!! He not only repaired our garage door he showed us proper maintenance to further the life of our door. He went above and beyond as a service technician. Ask for Justin when you need a repair on your garage door, he’s the best.
Jim DiMeo
Jim DiMeo
19:34 17 Sep 24
Harold came and immediately seen the problem and repaired the problem quickly and efficiently. Would definitely recommend Doors of Pontiac.
Kimberly Petrie
Kimberly Petrie
17:51 17 Sep 24
Fast serviceFriendly service workersEfficient problem-solvingReasonably-pricedHelpful office staffWould highly recommend!
David Walsh
David Walsh
16:26 17 Sep 24
David Benter
David Benter
16:01 17 Sep 24
Justin was very professional and answered all my questions. He also fixed our garage door issue that has plagued us for some time. Thank you for this outstanding service.
Jan Ciarlone
Jan Ciarlone
15:32 17 Sep 24
Keaton was so kind super helpful and quick great employee. I wish more companies had workers like him. Thank you very much for your help.
Bryan Galbraith
Bryan Galbraith
15:17 17 Sep 24
I had an issue with my garage door opener that I needed someone to take a look at. I called the office an a real person answered! The appointment was set for the next business day and the tech arrived right on time and solved the issued pretty quickly and gave some tips on how to prevent the issue in the future. Great service from beginning to end!
John Welch
John Welch
14:54 17 Sep 24
Harold was great and very informative.
James Bedor
James Bedor
19:31 16 Sep 24
Great work. They cleaned up well after themselves.
Frank Micielli
Frank Micielli
18:43 16 Sep 24
Keaton did an excellent job and was very efficient and thorough
William Villaire
William Villaire
11:42 16 Sep 24
Justin arrived within the appointment window and took care of my issue very quickly. He also helped me by educating me better as to how to maintain my door.
Regina Fronczak Roth
Regina Fronczak Roth
21:46 14 Sep 24
In the last 6 months, Doors of Pontiiac installed 2 new doors in my 53 year old home situated on a peninsula. Both doors were way out of line and could not be closed. It took 5 hours per door to get each door frame back in line. . Thanks to Jeff, Mike M, and Billy, I am safe and secure again in my home. Thank you Doors of Pontiac and their professional and dedicated crew.
Shar Butler
Shar Butler
18:00 13 Sep 24
Keaton was great and got everything working. He offered very professional service.
Tiffany H
Tiffany H
21:01 12 Sep 24
Justin was so friendly and efficient! Showed up on time. Got the job done in a half hour! Would definitely use this company again and highly recommend them to friends and family.
Michel Dickmeyer
Michel Dickmeyer
17:05 12 Sep 24
Appreciate the quick response and great job fixing my door
Andrew Gamalski
Andrew Gamalski
21:42 28 Mar 24
Donna Asp
Donna Asp
13:18 25 Mar 24
Joe
Joe
23:57 24 Mar 24
Barb LeMaigre
Barb LeMaigre
19:53 19 Mar 24
Focused sales, great recommendations. Install was Outstanding! Explained process, began tear out, install new, looks great. Gave 5 stars. No problems, no pressure sales, installed on time, and great quality.
Michael Caram
Michael Caram
13:20 22 Sep 23
Joe and an apprentice (Billy?) installed our new front door w/ sidelites yesterday. They removed and reinstalled an existing storm door as well. They were both polite, professional, efficient and did an excellent job. I was very impressed.Side note, Joe was very calm and understanding and a great teacher to his apprentice. As a sports coach to young kids, just listening to the way he explained everything was impressive. Not that Billy didn't understand, but having someone explain the reason for doing something so they actually learn the why is a great asset.
Brenda McGaughey
Brenda McGaughey
02:21 02 Apr 23
Mark Croteau
Mark Croteau
20:49 12 Oct 22
jacob Gebhart
jacob Gebhart
13:25 29 Jul 22
Mark is an exceptional and very down to earth guy. He is honest and will treat you with respect without pushing you into a sale. Anyone looking for new doors or windows should at least give mark a call and get a free estimate.
Tammie Jo
Tammie Jo
01:20 30 Jun 22
Mark came over for an estimate. It was the first time I’ve ever received the honest and up front approach to sales with no manipulation or overselling! He was very patient and respectful of with our many questions and very thorough with making sure we were quoted correctly. I would definitely recommend getting your work done through Doors of Pontiac - Livingston County and be sure to ask for Mark if you live in the area.
mark Croteau
mark Croteau
19:15 22 Apr 22
Heather McPh
Heather McPh
15:22 24 Mar 22
Great customer service! I was able to find everything I needed in one spot. they have a large variety of vinyl stop in many colors and even had a keypad for my garage door!
KK Marko
KK Marko
19:34 21 Mar 22
This place is great! Called and spoke with Vivian for service. She was quick and knowledgeable. A joy to talk to. Received same day service and the tech did a great job!My new "go to" for service. They also do entry doors as well. Highly recommend 👌
KK Marko
KK Marko
19:29 21 Mar 22
Great company. Very polite and knowledgeable. Had some garage door work done. Efficient. Will definitely call again
Michelle Anne
Michelle Anne
10:37 19 Mar 22
Stephen Rafferty
Stephen Rafferty
01:11 11 Nov 21
Donald Abbott
Donald Abbott
15:55 26 Feb 21
I have had dealings with this company. They have been great to work with. The staff really goes above and beyond the call of duty to make sure that their customers are taken care of.
Sue Zimmer
Sue Zimmer
18:02 17 Feb 21
Great service and professionalism. A pleasure to work with!
Vivian White
Vivian White
16:07 24 Dec 20
The company is super they've got an A.1 office manager the workers are courteous and we'll go the extra mile to help you very well pleased
Daniel Applefield
Daniel Applefield
13:22 24 Dec 20
Excellent work. Timely and professional. Great door company. The owner is very knowledgeable and stands behind his work.
Scott Levigne
Scott Levigne
13:12 24 Dec 20
Stephen Rafferty
Stephen Rafferty
12:11 24 Dec 20
New store in Brighton, so I thought I’d give it a try for some garage door parts, and they are so friendly and knowledgeable. Great quality products and value. I’ll be there again for service (my garage door springs have been on for many years, so they are probably almost due for an upgrade), and start dreaming about when I’ll visit them for a brand new front door!
Tom Lee
Tom Lee
03:11 06 Feb 19
The employees are very knowledgeable with many years of experience. They stock superior door sweeps, thresholds and Weatherstrip door stop sets.
Duane Barry
Duane Barry
18:17 30 Dec 18
I love this place, great products and amazing services everything from Windows, Entry doors, storm doors and garage doors, Even door walls, I can visit their store and purchase things off the shelf everything from garage door hinges, cables and rollers spray lube, door handles even that rubber weather strip on the bottom of my door, the one under my front door too, amazing services they get the job done, they'll come and replace my spring on my garage door at the same time do it complete inspection, their installers are professionals, for all those reasons i give five stars.
Michelle Anne
Michelle Anne
12:47 28 Dec 18
×
js_loader