Fiberglass vs. Steel Doors: Choosing the Right One

When picking a front door for your home, you need to consider a lot. The size, color, and design are all important, but before you can decide on any of those, you need to settle on what kind of materials you want for the door’s composition. There are quite a few options for entry doors, but two of the most common are fiberglass and steel. If you’ve narrowed your selection to these two types but don’t know which door to choose, we’re here to help you pick the right one.

The Argument for Steel

Let’s start by looking at steel. When most people picture a steel door, they think of the plain gray ones they’d find in the back of a business. However, residential steel doors are much more colorful and vibrant. Plus, you can even get ones with glass built into them.

While there’s a decent number of style options for steel doors, that’s often not the primary reason people buy them. They get them because of their strength. A steel door can hold up against anything from nasty weather to burglars trying to break into your house.

Unfortunately, this strength comes with a trade-off. Steel doors require lots of maintenance to keep them in good working order. If you put in the time to take care of your door, though, it’ll last you much longer than anything else on the market.

The Argument for Fiberglass

Now, let’s go over fiberglass and how it compares to steel. First off, fiberglass doors have many more design options than steel ones, making it easier to find a look that best fits the rest of your home. On top of that, it requires no maintenance, which is another huge plus over the competition.

While strong, fiberglass doors aren’t nearly as sturdy as steel. However, one pro they have is that they’re much more energy efficient. That’s not to say that steel isn’t good at saving energy—fiberglass is just better at it.

Which Should You Choose?

Now that you know the key differences between fiberglass and steel doors, which one should you choose? Since there’s no definitive best option, you need to go with the one that best fits your needs. If strength and security are priorities when it comes to your front door, steel is the best choice for you. On the other hand, you might want to go with fiberglass if you want to focus more on aspects like design and energy efficiency.

Regardless of which one you choose, Doors of Pontiac is the place to get it. We sell both steel and fiberglass residential entry doors, as well as many others. Once you decide which door you want, we’ll even professionally install it for you to help ensure it fits your home perfectly.

Leave a Comment

Steven Dasbach
Steven Dasbach
22:13 18 Apr 24
Andy did a great job installing our new garage door opener. He was very informative and knowledgeable. Wouldn’t hesitate to do business with them, great company.
Allison S
Allison S
01:03 18 Apr 24
Had a great experience with Doors of Pontiac! Karen was so helpful in the showroom and Mike, Billy, Drew and all of the install guys did an excellent job. We couldn’t be happier with our new front door and garage door!
Joanna Dwoskin
Joanna Dwoskin
14:03 17 Apr 24
Brandon Hansen
Brandon Hansen
20:11 16 Apr 24
Came out to our garage this afternoon to see that the old spring in the door had snapped. Called Doors of Pontiac and they had someone out within about an hour to make the repair. Devon was friendly, knowledgeable and got everything fixed and tuned up for us perfectly.
Kelly Oguin
Kelly Oguin
23:19 15 Apr 24
Same day appointment. The service technician (Drew) was very helpful explaining what needed to be done to fix my broken garage door.
Michael Blitz
Michael Blitz
15:52 14 Apr 24
Install went very well.Wish they had caulk to caulk in new exterior weather strip.Hope home buyer/current owner don’t fuss.Thank you so much,Mike Blitz
Lori Kinsey
Lori Kinsey
15:03 13 Apr 24
The repair man was very knowledgeable, professional, and helpful. Would recommend him to everyone.
Pastor Randy Bell Alpha Omega C.C.M.
Pastor Randy Bell Alpha Omega C.C.M.
15:48 12 Apr 24
We are thankful for the great service we receive from Doors of Pontiac...Especially from Dustin Killewald the installer he did a Great Job!
Wayne Soucie
Wayne Soucie
17:33 10 Apr 24
Very helpful service in picking out a new exterior and storm door for our home. Better priced than the big box stores.
Tina Maxbauer
Tina Maxbauer
20:54 09 Apr 24
Service was quick and easy. Excellent product!
traci raitt
traci raitt
20:14 09 Apr 24
This door is gorgeous! Thank you Door’s of Pontiac!!! Devin & Mike were incredible! They were polite and meticulous and cleaned up afterward. The install was done very well and I would highly recommend them.
Tony Montante
Tony Montante
14:58 09 Apr 24
Harold was was very efficient and the job was well done.
Jennifer Milne
Jennifer Milne
16:54 08 Apr 24
DD T (DD)
DD T (DD)
12:42 07 Apr 24
This is the 3rd time I’ve used Pontiac Doors! Professional , courteous , prompt are the words that come to mind. David Gadd was the salesperson that initially came to the house to help us find what we needed. Mike And Devon did the installation ..they were awesome! Before and after photos !
Mark
Mark
19:07 06 Apr 24
Carlotta Quince
Carlotta Quince
21:07 05 Apr 24
My experience with Doors of Pontiac was stellar! On the first visit (of two), Tech Andy arrived promptly to assess damage to my garage door. In no time, he explained clearly what needed to be done; made the repair; and reinforced the door's framework from the inside out. I also purchased a much needed backup garage door opener for a good price in the same visit. Kudos to Andy for his proficiency and professionalism! In setting up this visit, kudos also to Office rep, Yvette, whose caring, courtesy, and professionalism in taking down my concerns over the phone was palpable and made me look forward and relieved to seeing Andy show up at my door! For visit two, Office rep Staci Q was very effective in listening to my concerns and forwarding pics to Tech Bob prior to his arrival; to give him a solid "heads-up". While a door replacement seemed imminent, Bob demonstrated master craftsman skills and repaired the door and door locks to work as good as new! And for a price you can't beat! This company is the one to call when you need help with garage doors or ANY other doors in my opinion! Keep up the good work!And thank you.
Hendricks Richard
Hendricks Richard
20:27 05 Apr 24
Andrew Berlinski
Andrew Berlinski
19:09 05 Apr 24
Great Products and Service! Doors Of Pontiac has always provided exceptional quality! They even got me taken care of on same day service calls! Consider this company for any of your garage door and home door needs!
Kara Nowak
Kara Nowak
19:04 05 Apr 24
Andy came out the same day I called to fix our keypad that wasn't working. He replaced it, made sure our remotes were working in our cars and did it fast, friendly & professional. Great Company to work with.
Craig Nott
Craig Nott
17:31 04 Apr 24
Andy was very helpful, did everything in a timely fashion. He also cleaned up and disposed of all the old parts and left the garage spotless.
Mark Jean
Mark Jean
17:29 04 Apr 24
Tim Oneill
Tim Oneill
19:29 02 Apr 24
The service was great.They were there at my house in 1 hour. Andy is a awesome technician thank you
Catherine Pawlowski
Catherine Pawlowski
18:39 01 Apr 24
Responded the same day with spring replacements on garage door. Very happy with the work.
kathleen kirt
kathleen kirt
14:41 31 Mar 24
Very informative installer. Cleaned up after install. Cared about me and if I was happy.
Ed Jesionowski
Ed Jesionowski
19:21 29 Mar 24
The entire team was great...appreciate getting the garage door up as soon as we found money to pay for it. Drew was fantastic with the install....thanks again!!! Ed & Irina Jesionowski
Tracy Roche
Tracy Roche
18:57 29 Mar 24
Quick response to call for garage door spring failure, on time and fast repair. Really appreciate the quick turnaround!
Andrew Gamalski
Andrew Gamalski
21:42 28 Mar 24
Clark Beebe
Clark Beebe
19:59 28 Mar 24
Mark Frawley
Mark Frawley
17:49 28 Mar 24
Qazim Sinakoli
Qazim Sinakoli
16:47 28 Mar 24
nice beautiful clean and professionalDustin installation guy does really good job very happy with the job
Kathy Reinhart
Kathy Reinhart
14:18 27 Mar 24
Mark Wolowiec
Mark Wolowiec
19:52 26 Mar 24
Prompt expert service from Harold at Doors of Pontic. Great advice given regarding ongoing maintenance and future concerns to watch for. Nice job!
Donna Asp
Donna Asp
13:18 25 Mar 24
Daniel Gomez Inspires
Daniel Gomez Inspires
01:57 25 Mar 24
Alan Asp and his team are phenomenal! Their customer service was the cherry on top. If you need a door or door repair, we highly recommend them.
Mark Joseph
Mark Joseph
20:52 23 Mar 24
Alejandro Cervantes
Alejandro Cervantes
14:49 22 Mar 24
Barb LeMaigre
Barb LeMaigre
19:53 19 Mar 24
Focused sales, great recommendations. Install was Outstanding! Explained process, began tear out, install new, looks great. Gave 5 stars. No problems, no pressure sales, installed on time, and great quality.
Barb LeMaigre
Barb LeMaigre
19:49 19 Mar 24
Focused sales, great recommendations. Install by Mike M. Outstanding! Explained process, began tear out, install new, looks great, level, swings nice. Mike took time to put Xtra insulation and show us leveling process. Gave 5 stars. No problems, no pressure sales, installed on time, and great quality.
Nicki Morris
Nicki Morris
15:26 18 Mar 24
On time. Professional. Work completed as expected
Justin O'Connor
Justin O'Connor
20:46 15 Mar 24
The technician was timely and completed the job quickly . Thanks Doors of Pontiac.
Adewunmi Adeyemo
Adewunmi Adeyemo
17:50 15 Mar 24
Eva
Eva
16:05 15 Mar 24
Doors of Pontiac makes doors easy. We met at the home show in Novi. We have used them for a front entry door system and garage door with opener, we are happy with the products and the customer service. Definitely recommend.
Kari Melkonian
Kari Melkonian
22:19 13 Mar 24
Excellent, prompt and reliable service! My technician (Harold) arrived on time, was courteous and efficient. Fair price for garage door repair - will definitely use again!
Kathryn McKinsey
Kathryn McKinsey
01:10 13 Mar 24
Always our first choice. Again, this company has quick response, knowledgeable staff and courteous service. Highly recommend.
Laura Polick
Laura Polick
17:27 12 Mar 24
It was excellent service. They called me right away. Then I almost immediately had a text from the service man that he was on his way, he came very quickly, and did the repair checked everything out and was done within 20 minutes!
Tom Hogan
Tom Hogan
15:05 12 Mar 24
Drew was great in explaining the different types of garage door opener systems available. He was very friendly, knowledgable and professional in doing a great job!
Alan Cooper
Alan Cooper
19:31 11 Mar 24
Company responded quickly and efficiently to my request. Installer was professional, pleasant and effective. New garage door in place within in 90minutes. Explained its operation and installed in the GDO in my car. Look forward to many years of use. Thank you very much.
Madelynn Lange
Madelynn Lange
18:53 11 Mar 24
Excellent service and installation as always. Would highly recommend to anyone
Michael Watson
Michael Watson
17:11 09 Mar 24
Great job, Dustin was friendly and completed repairs in a professional and timely manner.
Justdebbie
Justdebbie
21:52 08 Mar 24
Fast, excellent service.
Darryl J.
Darryl J.
04:38 08 Mar 24
Jalal Panah
Jalal Panah
15:17 07 Mar 24
The technician was able to address the problemand expertly repaired the garage doors. I am very satisfied with this gentleman's work.
Phil Weber
Phil Weber
21:13 05 Mar 24
No complaints
James CURTIS Beachum Ii RIA
James CURTIS Beachum Ii RIA
15:46 04 Mar 24
Awesome awesome thanks buddy thanks again for your way too nice
Hussien Fekaiki
Hussien Fekaiki
17:24 01 Mar 24
Great work and professionals 👍
Paul Fryer
Paul Fryer
14:45 01 Mar 24
My garage door fell off it's track at night I contacted Doors of Pontiac at 8am the next morning and they had an inspector at my house by 8:30 to give me a quote and to identify the full scope of work and the correct color. by 12:30 the installers were there with my new door and had it completely installed by 3:30 and not just the door all new track overhead rod with a new spring. Best of all the price shocked me as I thought the quote was just for a door not all the other material.Bottom line this company blew me away for courtesy , friendliness and professionalism I would recommend them to anyone !
Yvonne Stokes
Yvonne Stokes
17:00 27 Feb 24
The Doors of Pontiac saved our life! We were trapped in our garage due to a broken cable and needed a quick fix. They arrived the morning after the cable broke and subsequently repaired our garage door. We would have been prisoners, but doors of Pontiac set us free! Respectful, courteous, and knowledgeable about their job!
Donard Maniaci
Donard Maniaci
14:45 27 Feb 24
Doors of Pontiac just gets it done. Super easy to deal with and it's done right the first time.
Jeanne Teague
Jeanne Teague
21:48 26 Feb 24
Great company from the person to answers the phone to the person who comes to your home and takes care of your garage door needs. You won't be disappointed by this company!!!
Patricia M
Patricia M
21:35 26 Feb 24
Tech was very knowledgeable, efficient and respectful.
Patrick Doig
Patrick Doig
15:32 26 Feb 24
Sam Jomaa
Sam Jomaa
19:22 23 Feb 24
Best service
John Truskowski
John Truskowski
19:05 23 Feb 24
I’ve turned to Pontiac doors numerous times and the professionalism and attention to detail is fantastic. They are responsive and able to help in a timely manner.
L Coleman
L Coleman
20:37 21 Feb 24
Andy did a fantastic job on my new garage door opener.
Jere D
Jere D
19:15 21 Feb 24
Quick fix thanks
Sepi Shushtari
Sepi Shushtari
16:43 21 Feb 24
Julie Finch
Julie Finch
01:22 21 Feb 24
We had a fantastic experience with Doors of Pontiac from start to finish and absolutely LOVE our new front door. Our installers, Michael and Devin, were prompt, professional, qualified, helpful and did an amazing job!
Karen R
Karen R
21:45 20 Feb 24
Doors of Pontiac were wonderful from start to finish. Yvette gave me a great quote over the phone, arranged a time for a measurement and then was able to schedule an installation the next day. I was thrilled. Dan installed my garage door and cleaned everything up. I am very pleased to highly recommend them.
Cindy Stolber
Cindy Stolber
19:42 20 Feb 24
Andy was very nice and quickly replaced the broken spring on my garage door. I appreciate the same day service.
Harriet Duquette
Harriet Duquette
12:04 16 Feb 24
Requested service call at 7:30 am. Repair completed before 4:00 pm same day. Service rep Michael Jones did a great job. Prompt, courteous, quality service. Highly recommend.
Mike Pogarch
Mike Pogarch
00:26 16 Feb 24
Harold Junek did a great job replacing our garage door springs and cables. The door system runs smoothly and quietly. Thank you!
R Murphy
R Murphy
18:48 15 Feb 24
Michael, our service tech was knowledgeable, professional and polite. He made sure all my questions were answered and made sure we were happy with the job and install. I would highly recommend him again. It was slightly more than we expected to pay with more bells and whistles than we probably need, but it seems to be a really good system. Thank you.
KOS_SEEHOPE SEEHOPE
KOS_SEEHOPE SEEHOPE
17:42 15 Feb 24
jason mcintyre
jason mcintyre
19:54 14 Feb 24
Kris Ball
Kris Ball
20:34 13 Feb 24
First time very pleased customer. The tech was extremely helpful & did a great job fixing my problem. I would recommend this company to anyone in need of their assistance. Thank you!
Mike Snyder
Mike Snyder
17:52 12 Feb 24
Excellent, timely service. Tech (Michael Jones) was great, and I appreciate how quickly everything was done. Highly recommend this company!
Myke Dorsey
Myke Dorsey
14:48 12 Feb 24
Excellent customer service and fast response after I had an issue after the installation. Fair pricing and they didn’t try to price gouge me.
Virgil Schleich
Virgil Schleich
20:16 10 Feb 24
Michael was great. He explained everything clearly and made reasonable suggestions. Friendly and efficient. Great job!
Louis Rabedeau
Louis Rabedeau
17:35 10 Feb 24
Amar George
Amar George
21:59 09 Feb 24
Great People and Outstanding ServiceAppreciate the friendly attitude also.Thank you
betty malmquist
betty malmquist
18:03 07 Feb 24
Harold was amazing and very knowledgeable. Repairs were done so fast and accurate. Thanks for taking the stress off of us.
Ann Serna
Ann Serna
16:59 07 Feb 24
Installer was well advised, he connected up autos & phone access. Was able to explain entire process and all bells & whistles and benefits of opener.
Dave Hall
Dave Hall
20:33 06 Feb 24
Great service, from the estimate (David Gadd) even with having to order the door it only took a week from order to the installation (Drew & Dustin). New door was installed in under 2 hours. Awesome job. Thanks
Henry Storm
Henry Storm
15:44 06 Feb 24
Timely, professional, trustworthy. Long, long time satisfied customer. One stop shop for all doors. Highly recommend Doors of Pontiac!
Jason Ballantyne
Jason Ballantyne
16:30 04 Feb 24
Troy Herndon
Troy Herndon
16:25 29 Jan 24
S Poloney
S Poloney
17:07 27 Jan 24
We’ve used their services for our garage door twice now and both were great!!Excellent service!!Dustin was awesome!
Matthew Adams
Matthew Adams
20:19 26 Jan 24
Garage door looks great! Guys were very professional.
Robert Harrell
Robert Harrell
15:49 24 Jan 24
They always do a great job!!
Eloise Young
Eloise Young
11:44 23 Jan 24
Susan DeLano
Susan DeLano
20:32 16 Jan 24
Nancy Winar
Nancy Winar
15:50 04 Jan 24
My experience with Doors of Pontiac was great. I contacted them late in the morning and there was a serviceperson (Harold) here by 4:00 pm. By 4:30 the door was repaired, the fee was very reasonable, and my garage door works better than ever (better than when I had general maintenance done by different company previously). Harold also gave me some suggestions on how to keep the door functioning well in the future. I will definitely call this company again should the need arise.
Natalie Larkin
Natalie Larkin
06:35 23 Dec 23
Exceptional service from consultation to installation on 12/19/23. Installer Joe was an expert from start to finish and so detailed and careful with my beautiful new front door and locks. Joe made me confident at my door choice, with his knowledge and easy patient manner. Not a speck of dust left. Wish all businesses had this kind of pride in workmanship and customer relationships. Thank you!
Marlene B
Marlene B
15:35 09 Dec 23
Harold was fantastic and did a great job installing new springs and cables. I have used Doors of Pontiac before a few times over the years and each time, great service and and a happy customer. Thank you!
Maryjo Green
Maryjo Green
20:05 08 Dec 23
Doors of Pontiac was great to work with especially our installer Mike. He and his team did a great job installing our new front door. We were very happy with the work.
Lynn Schwartz
Lynn Schwartz
18:40 05 Dec 23
Recently had my front entrance and storm door installed by Doors of Pontiac. Joe did a great job with the install and cleanup. I have used them in the past for a new garage door. i would recommend them.
Brian Simmons
Brian Simmons
14:41 11 Nov 23
We are SOOOOO happy that we went with a local company that has been around for a long time and especially Doors of Pontiac!! Michelle made it so easy to pick the right door, color and glass options for our home! There was plenty of options to choose from. Randy and Billy did a fantastic job, going above and beyond, when they had to do a little more work to shore up the base plate where the door would sit. Even when this meant shaving some off of the top frame of the door opening so everything would fit. And it fit beautifully!! We are super happy with how everything turned out!! Thank you Michelle, Randy and Billy for a job WELL DONE!! (before and after pics)
Nicholas Cabrera
Nicholas Cabrera
22:56 09 Nov 23
Joe installed two doors for me today. He was friendly, transparent, and did a phenomenal job! Could not recommend doors of Pontiac, or Joe more!
Colleen K. Grigorian
Colleen K. Grigorian
15:02 08 Nov 23
New beautiful garage door installed yesterday by Dan and Nick. Great, thorough courteous service, always great customer service from the crew at Doors of Pontiac. We've been doing business with them for years. Highly recommend.
Rachel Cretsinger
Rachel Cretsinger
15:49 07 Nov 23
The ladies in the office are very knowledgeable and kind. Joe came replaced our door. He was very respectful. There was no mess left. He knew what he was doing …. GREAT JOB!!!! Thank y’all so much!!!!
Deborah Highstreet
Deborah Highstreet
00:23 07 Nov 23
I got my new door today Joe was on time and very nice and did an excellent job cleaned every up I couldn't be happier thanks Joe
Michael Caram
Michael Caram
13:20 22 Sep 23
Joe and an apprentice (Billy?) installed our new front door w/ sidelites yesterday. They removed and reinstalled an existing storm door as well. They were both polite, professional, efficient and did an excellent job. I was very impressed.Side note, Joe was very calm and understanding and a great teacher to his apprentice. As a sports coach to young kids, just listening to the way he explained everything was impressive. Not that Billy didn't understand, but having someone explain the reason for doing something so they actually learn the why is a great asset.
Brenda McGaughey
Brenda McGaughey
02:21 02 Apr 23
Mark Croteau
Mark Croteau
20:49 12 Oct 22
jacob Gebhart
jacob Gebhart
13:25 29 Jul 22
Mark is an exceptional and very down to earth guy. He is honest and will treat you with respect without pushing you into a sale. Anyone looking for new doors or windows should at least give mark a call and get a free estimate.
Tammie Jo
Tammie Jo
01:20 30 Jun 22
Mark came over for an estimate. It was the first time I’ve ever received the honest and up front approach to sales with no manipulation or overselling! He was very patient and respectful of with our many questions and very thorough with making sure we were quoted correctly. I would definitely recommend getting your work done through Doors of Pontiac - Livingston County and be sure to ask for Mark if you live in the area.
mark Croteau
mark Croteau
19:15 22 Apr 22
Heather McPh
Heather McPh
15:22 24 Mar 22
Great customer service! I was able to find everything I needed in one spot. they have a large variety of vinyl stop in many colors and even had a keypad for my garage door!
KK Marko
KK Marko
19:34 21 Mar 22
This place is great! Called and spoke with Vivian for service. She was quick and knowledgeable. A joy to talk to. Received same day service and the tech did a great job!My new "go to" for service. They also do entry doors as well. Highly recommend 👌
KK Marko
KK Marko
19:29 21 Mar 22
Great company. Very polite and knowledgeable. Had some garage door work done. Efficient. Will definitely call again
Michelle Anne
Michelle Anne
10:37 19 Mar 22
Stephen Rafferty
Stephen Rafferty
01:11 11 Nov 21
Donald Abbott
Donald Abbott
15:55 26 Feb 21
I have had dealings with this company. They have been great to work with. The staff really goes above and beyond the call of duty to make sure that their customers are taken care of.
Sue Zimmer
Sue Zimmer
18:02 17 Feb 21
Great service and professionalism. A pleasure to work with!
Vivian White
Vivian White
16:07 24 Dec 20
The company is super they've got an A.1 office manager the workers are courteous and we'll go the extra mile to help you very well pleased
Daniel Applefield
Daniel Applefield
13:22 24 Dec 20
Excellent work. Timely and professional. Great door company. The owner is very knowledgeable and stands behind his work.
Scott Levigne
Scott Levigne
13:12 24 Dec 20
Stephen Rafferty
Stephen Rafferty
12:11 24 Dec 20
New store in Brighton, so I thought I’d give it a try for some garage door parts, and they are so friendly and knowledgeable. Great quality products and value. I’ll be there again for service (my garage door springs have been on for many years, so they are probably almost due for an upgrade), and start dreaming about when I’ll visit them for a brand new front door!
Tom Lee
Tom Lee
03:11 06 Feb 19
The employees are very knowledgeable with many years of experience. They stock superior door sweeps, thresholds and Weatherstrip door stop sets.
Duane Barry
Duane Barry
18:17 30 Dec 18
I love this place, great products and amazing services everything from Windows, Entry doors, storm doors and garage doors, Even door walls, I can visit their store and purchase things off the shelf everything from garage door hinges, cables and rollers spray lube, door handles even that rubber weather strip on the bottom of my door, the one under my front door too, amazing services they get the job done, they'll come and replace my spring on my garage door at the same time do it complete inspection, their installers are professionals, for all those reasons i give five stars.
Michelle Anne
Michelle Anne
12:47 28 Dec 18
×
js_loader